Shop Stories

Inside Mesozoic Tiki Bar: 30 Parties Turned Away and One Four-Pizza Oven

A pizza pop-up turned into a 4,300 square foot tiki bar in an old Nashua brewery taproom. Two months in, they're turning away about 30 parties on a busy night, with no bank loans and one oven that fits four pizzas.

Inside Mesozoic Tiki Bar: 30 Parties Turned Away and One Four-Pizza Oven

Josh started out making pizzas on his back porch during COVID. He used to be a project manager in construction. He didn't want to go back to that, so he made pizza his job.

Now he and his business partner run Mesozoic Tiki Bar in downtown Nashua, New Hampshire. It's a pizza place and tiki bar inside an old brewery taproom. They'd been open two months when I walked in, and they'd turned away about 30 parties the night before.

The numbers

  • A little under 4,300 square feet.
  • Open two months at the time of filming.
  • About 30 parties turned away on one of their busiest nights.
  • Some regulars already come in two nights a week.
  • One oven. It holds four 14-inch pizzas at a time, and a pizza takes about 6 to 8 minutes.
  • One pizza size: 14 inches.
  • A busy night's staff: two bartenders, two servers, three in the kitchen including Josh, and no host.
  • Zero bank loans. They self-funded and ran a Kickstarter that hit its goal.

They took over a space they already knew

Josh was already doing pizza in this building with the brewery. In September that fell apart. His partner reached out to the brewery owner and asked if he'd sell. They kept talking, and in February they signed the lease.

The pizza oven was already in the building, so they didn't have to buy one. Josh kept the pizza setup where it was, moved a reach-in up front, and added a prep station. Customers can watch the pizzas get made, and he says people love that.

There's no commercial hood in the back kitchen. They're grandfathered in with two hood systems, so they cook on a TurboChef and a self-contained fryer with fire suppression. The mixer has one outlet it can use, so he wheels it out and plugs it in every time. Not a normal kitchen. They made it work anyway.

Kickstarter instead of a bank

They set up tiers. One tier got a dough and pizza class, with a starter to take home and a cheat sheet. Another was called "buy us a table." Give enough money and you get a plaque on the side of a table. Backers also got t-shirts and an invite to a soft open just for Kickstarter backers and friends and family.

The table plaques keep paying off. Someone came in for the first time and asked to sit at their table. That's a customer who showed up already invested in the place.

Prep heavy, because the kitchen can't do more

They've maxed out the equipment in the back. So the question became how to keep ticket times down with a kitchen that can't handle much more. Josh's answer is prep. They make their marinades and sauces in house. They know their pars. They look at reservations and walk-ins and prep for that, every day, not a week ahead.

The menu on the pizza side is tight too. One size, 14 inches, out of one oven that holds four. Josh says they're getting to the point where they'll have to upgrade it.

The other thing he's working on is letting go. Josh was coming in at 9 in the morning to prep because if he didn't, it wasn't getting done. Now they have opening and closing procedures and build sheets, and he's learning to step back and let his staff run them. Next year he plans to add an operations manager and more staff.

What a pizza owner can steal

  • If you're raising money, sell something people can see. A plaque on a table turns a backer into a regular.
  • When your equipment is the bottleneck, fix it with prep. Know your pars and prep daily off your reservations and walk-ins.
  • Check what's already in the building. They took over a space that came with a pizza oven, so they didn't have to buy one.

Mesozoic Tiki Bar is at 97 Main Street in Nashua, NH. It's on the Pizzeria Insider shop map with every other place we've visited.

If you want to talk through this stuff with other owners, that's what SPM PRO is for.

Get one of these every Tuesday.

A real shop, the real numbers, and one thing worth trying. Free.