podcast

Posting Every Day: Facebook Almost Doubled, TikTok Barely Moved

Three weeks into my posting experiment. What I'm posting on each platform, how often, and what the numbers look like with zero ad spend.

Posting Every Day: Facebook Almost Doubled, TikTok Barely Moved

About a month ago I set a goal for Smart Pizza Marketing: 100,000 followers on Instagram, 50,000 on Facebook and 50,000 on TikTok by the end of May 2027.

I talk about social media all the time. Post consistently, test, look at what works. But I get busy too, and I wasn't doing what I tell owners to do. So I started posting every day on every platform, and I'm sharing the results as I go.

No ads. No influencers. All organic.

Listen to (and watch) the full episode on Spotify

The numbers

  • Instagram: about 35,000 followers in October. 39,742 now.
  • Facebook: about 7,000 followers in October. 13,436 now.
  • TikTok: about 6,200 followers in October. 7,126 now.
  • Instagram, last 30 days: 1.4 million views and 2.4 million accounts reached, with more views from non-followers than followers.
  • Facebook, last 28 days: 2.5 million views, views up over 11,000%, and about 4,800 new followers. The top reel did 865,000 views.
  • Money spent on ads: $0.

Why I set the goal

I tell pizza owners to post every day. I've said it on this podcast for years.

Then I'd get busy with clients, SPM PRO and traveling for Slice, and go days without posting. I was making the same excuse I hear from owners all the time: no time, no ideas.

That excuse is gone now. ChatGPT and Claude can look at what you posted, tell you what worked and help you come up with the next 30 ideas. You couldn't do that three years ago.

So I picked a number and made it public. Followers aren't everything, but they're easy to track and easy to show you, so you can watch it happen with me.

The goals aren't the same on every platform because I'm not starting in the same place. In October I had about 35,000 followers on Instagram, 7,000 on Facebook and 6,200 on TikTok. Hitting 50,000 on Facebook means growing it more than seven times over.

TikTok I walked away from. A couple years ago I took it from zero to 6,000 followers in 30 days, then quit because I didn't think pizza owners were on there and I didn't have the time to do it right. Owners are on there now. So I'm back.

Instagram: one reel a day

I only post once a day to the feed, almost always a reel.

The ones that do best have a number attached. A crazy amount of pizza, a big sales number, a hidden pizza spot inside a coffee shop. Somebody scrolling has to stop and go "whoa."

After posts go live, I use ChatGPT and Claude to pull the data and tell me what worked and what didn't. After 30 posts I ask: what were the top five or 10, why did they work, and what do they have in common? Then I go back into our content archive and find more like them.

That's the part most owners never did. You could see which posts did well, but not why, so you'd run out of ideas. Now that takes a few minutes.

I don't use AI to make the images or the videos. I use it to analyze and brainstorm.

Facebook: two to four posts a day

Facebook has surprised me the most. I went from about 7,000 to over 13,000 followers in a month.

What goes out every day:

  • The Instagram reel, cross posted
  • A second reel uploaded straight to Facebook
  • A text post that asks a question
  • A text post with a piece of advice or something I noticed

The questions build engagement. Owners love talking about their own shops. For the advice posts, I talk my thoughts into ChatGPT and it cleans up the grammar. It's still my words.

In a mastermind call I run, someone said their plan was to post two or three times a week on Facebook. I told them that's basically zero. You'll get a couple likes from people who already follow you, but you won't reach anyone new.

So I went the other way. Post as much as you can without losing followers, and run the page like you're running ads without paying for them.

TikTok: the one that isn't working yet

TikTok has been the hardest. I'm posting two videos a day and I've only gained a few hundred followers.

A reel that hits on Instagram usually hits on TikTok, but not always. What I'm seeing: the more a video gets people talking to each other in the comments, the more reach it gets. Shares and saves matter a lot there too.

If you have thin skin, don't read the TikTok comments.

What I'm not doing is TikTok Live, and it works. If you own a pizza shop, go live at the same time every day while you're making pizza during your busy hour. Do it for 30 days and people will come back to watch.

I may need to hire someone to do TikTok the right way. I've been doing all of this myself because I want to know what actually works before I tell you to do it.

Why I won't pay for ads

These platforms need good content. If everything on them is garbage, nobody stays, and they can't sell ads. So if you make content people actually want to watch, they'll send you viewers for free.

If you sell a product, ads can work in the short term. For a local pizza shop, good content is what keeps paying off.

Where I think this ends up

  • Facebook to 50,000: most confident. We might get there before May.
  • Instagram to 100,000: close, as long as we get a few big hits. I've been laying off memes, but I might lean into them a little more.
  • TikTok to 50,000: least confident, unless I change how I'm doing it.

I'll do a check-in at the three month mark.

What a pizza owner can steal

  • Post more than you think you should. Two or three times a week on Facebook won't grow anything.
  • Lead with numbers. Pizzas sold, a huge order, a busy Friday. Give people a reason to stop scrolling.
  • After 30 days, have ChatGPT or Claude look at your top and bottom posts and tell you why. Then make more of the winners.
  • Use Facebook text posts. Ask questions people want to answer.
  • If you have someone younger on your team who's good at social, hand them TikTok and go live during your busiest hour every day for 30 days.
  • Watch views from non-followers. That's how you know you're reaching new customers.

My challenge to you: pick one platform, write down where you're at today and where you want to be by May 2027, and DM me on Instagram at @smartpizzamarketing. Let's do it together.


Thanks to our sponsor

The brand that makes this podcast happen

Stanislaus Food Products

Stanislaus Food Products

A family run company and one of the staples in the pizza world. California tomatoes, with a variety for pretty much any style of pizza you make.

Visit Stanislaus →

If you want to talk through this stuff with other owners, that's what SPM PRO is for.

Get one of these every Tuesday.

A real shop, the real numbers, and one thing worth trying. Free.