Shop Stories

Tiki Bars, Bread Ovens and Pizza Screens: What I Learned in Toronto

Five shops around Toronto and Hamilton: a tiki bar that's only open part of the week, a Best Pizza winner baked in a bread oven, and why almost everyone up there cooks on screens.

Tiki Bars, Bread Ovens and Pizza Screens: What I Learned in Toronto

I just got back from Toronto and Hamilton. While I was posting from the shops on Instagram, a lot of you sent me questions. Instead of answering them one at a time, I answered all of them on the podcast.

Five shops: MaiPai, Boa Bakery, Cowabunga, One Night Only and Pizzeria Badiali. The full videos from each one are coming to the Slice YouTube channel over the next few weeks.

Listen to the full episode on Spotify

MaiPai: a tiki bar that serves great pizza

MaiPai is in Hamilton, about an hour south of Toronto. It's a tiki bar that serves Detroit style pizza. Salar went for a tiki bar first that serves great pizza, not a pizzeria with a tiki theme. That's the exception.

Someone asked me if the experience is as important as the pizza. Yes. But experience isn't just what people see when they walk in. It's how you answer the phone. It's how someone hands a pizza to the person picking it up. If your experience is great and your pizza has a bad day, the experience gives you a chance to get that customer back.

What surprised me most is how little Salar works. He's only open a few nights a week, for a few hours a night. Online ordering and reservations fill up fast. His staff knows exactly when they're working and how many pizzas they're making. And he gets to take vacations and go on motorcycle trips across the country. Not everybody can do that. But if your product and experience are good enough, you can sell the same amount in a shorter window and have a life outside the shop.

Boa Bakery: Best Pizza out of a bread oven

Boa isn't a pizza shop. It's a bakery. Kevin started out delivering bread, the way they do it back home in Portugal. Then he got into pizza, built his dough off the bread recipe, and won Best Pizza at Pizza Expo.

He's doing it in a big industrial bread oven that only gets to about 540 degrees. People asked me if that changed my mind about how important the oven is. It didn't. Kevin is a professional bread maker. He knows how to work that oven. The average pizza maker can't buy that oven and make the same pizza. An oven is a tool. The better the tool, the easier the job. But it's still just a tool.

I told him he should open a pizza shop. There's a lot more margin in pizza than in bread.

Cowabunga: what the second location really costs

I've known Justin from pizza photography for something like 10 years. He opened Cowabunga with his partner Andy, who runs operations. They have two shops in the Hamilton area, a third on the way, and Justin opened one in Bangkok.

Andy is hyper focused on consistency. He's watching customers eat. He's watching his team make every pizza. A lot of the best pizza makers are like that.

Their first shop was small and takeout only. It did great. They used that money to open a bigger, full restaurant, and Andy said it cost more and took longer than they thought. When it opened it wasn't as busy as they expected, so the first shop was carrying the second one. Now that it's busy, they deal with the other side of it: people driving from far away and waiting over an hour because there's only so much room in the oven.

Needing more space because you're too busy is a great problem to have. It's a lot better than the opposite, which is too much space, not enough customers and a pile of debt.

One Night Only: from the backyard to 450 square feet

Luke started making pizza at home during COVID and selling it out of the back one night at a time. He built a following, sold out over and over, then found a 450 square foot shop with two Blodgett ovens and a tiny dough room in the basement.

Nothing fancy. He makes pizza and that's about it. But he proved the concept before he put all his money in, and he kept the rent cheap. That's the smart way to do it.

He's looking at a second shop, and I think he'll do a version of the same thing, just with a better layout. When you don't know what you don't know, your first layout is never as good as you want it to be.

Pizzeria Badiali: why everyone in Toronto cooks on screens

Badiali is one of the best known slice shops in Toronto. Ryan came from fine dining. I visited the second location, and the build out was great: a big Pizza Master oven and a kitchen that was moving like a machine an hour before open.

Part of why it blew up is influencers. Once one creator does well with a shop, others show up to make the same content. But the pizza lives up to it, so they get locals and visitors. Monthly seasonal pizzas keep the menu fresh, and the classics stay consistent.

The thing that surprised me on this whole trip: almost every shop cooks on screens. Badiali, Cowabunga, One Night Only. I asked why. Same answer every time. It's hard to find people who can launch a pizza off a peel consistently, and when they leave you start over. So they get it in the oven on a screen, then pull the screen after a minute or two. I tasted the pizza. It didn't make much of a difference.

Would I do it in my own shop? No. I'm not going for scale. But I get why they do.

What a pizza owner can steal

  • Experience is everything except the food. The phone, the pickup, the handoff. Fix those before the decor.
  • Fewer hours can mean the same sales and a better life, if the product is strong enough.
  • Start small. Prove it. Then grow. A second location is going to cost more and take longer than you think.
  • An oven is a tool. Skill matters more.
  • If you can't find people who can work a peel, screens aren't the end of the world.

Where should we go next? Send me your city on Instagram at @smartpizzamarketing.


Thanks to our sponsors

The brands that make this podcast happen

Mike's Hot Honey

Mike's Hot Honey

Mike's Hot Honey was born on the Hellboy pizza at Paulie Gee's in Brooklyn and is now on menus all over the country. Even up in Toronto, a lot of the most popular shops had it on their pizzas.

Visit Mike’s Hot Honey →
Cheese Hog

Cheese Hog

Buy the block and shred it yourself. You save money on cheese, and the Cheese Hog does it in about half the time you would on a Hobart. Super easy to use.

Visit Cheese Hog →
Stanislaus Food Products

Stanislaus Food Products

A family run company and one of the staples in the pizza world. California tomatoes, with a variety for pretty much any style of pizza you make.

Visit Stanislaus →

If you want to talk through this stuff with other owners, that's what SPM PRO is for.

Get one of these every Tuesday.

A real shop, the real numbers, and one thing worth trying. Free.